2000 - Clive's Top Albums of Every Year Challenge

March 28, 2025 by Clive in Clive, Music, Clive's Album Challenge

Since 2020, I’ve been ranking and reviewing the top 5 albums - plus a fair few extras - according to users on rateyourmusic.com (think IMDB for music) from every year from 1960 to the present. If you want to know more, I wrote an introduction to the ‘challenge’ here. You can also read all the other entries I’ve written so far by heading to the lovely index page here.

And so we enter another decade, the ‘noughties’ as people like to call them. I was entering year 8 in the year 2000, and so we’re starting to get into the years where I can actually remember albums coming out. Most of these though, I was totally unaware of at the time - being more interested in catching all the Pokemon, and other such year 8 things.

More widely, 2000 was the year that mad cow disease panicked Europe, Yugoslavians overthrew Milosevic, and the abortion pill won approval in the US.

We’re here for the music though - and here’s rateyourmusic.com users’ top 5 of the year:

#1 Radiohead - Kid A
#2 Godspeed You Black Emperor! - Lift Yr Skinny Fists Like Antennas to Heaven!
#3 The Avalanches - Since I left You
#4 Boris - Flood
#5 Electric Wizard - Dopethrone

And as always, some others from further down the list - including some to make sure we have at least some female artists.

#6 Deftones - White Pony
#7 D’Angelo - Voodoo
#8 At the Drive-In - Relationship of Command
#9 Modest Mouse - The Moon & Antarctica
#10 Sheena Ringo - Shouso Strip
#11 Erykah Badu - Mama’s Gun
#20 Yo La Tengo - And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out
#21 PJ Harvey - Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea
#38 Advantage Lucy - Station

That’s 14, when I was supposed to be cutting down the amount of albums per year. This is quite probably the highest scoring year of the challenge yet, so the glut of albums was entirely worth it.

“Flood is the third studio album by Japanese experimental band Boris. It consists of a single 70-minute title-track that is broken into four movements.

While Flood did not receive many reviews upon release, it has become a cult classic among fans, prompting the band to play it in its entirety every night of their 2013 US-based Residency Tour.” - Wikipedia

An ambitious sprawling 70 minute album that is essentially one 30 minute instrumental piece padded out by 40 minutes of noise. Some say the noise adds to it, which I get to some extent, but I think it milks it just a bit too much, and an edit of this album down to 40 minutes would have made it genuinely amazing. Flood II (particularly Wata's transcendent solo) and Flood III are a genuinely spectacular heart to a bloated album.

SP: Flood II, Flood III

7/10

“White Pony is the third studio album by the American alternative metal band Deftones. The album marked a significant growth in the band's sound, incorporating influences from post-hardcore, trip hop, shoegaze, progressive rock, and post-rock into the alternative metal sound which they had become known for. Upon its release and retrospectively, the album was met with critical acclaim, and is regarded by fans and critics alike as one of the band's most mature outings at that point” - Wikipedia

The quintessential Nu metal sound. Dense riffs, metallic whispers, and that vocal style. The riffs on this one could shake mountains. Strange that I didn't listen to this growing up, as this would have been my jam.

8/10

“Shōso Strip is the second studio album by Japanese singer and songwriter Ringo Sheena, The album debuted at #1 and has sold over 2,332,000 copies. It was certified two million copies by the RIAJ. In September 2007, Rolling Stone Japan rated the album at number 89 on its list of the "100 Greatest Japanese Rock Albums of All Time." - Wikipedia

It sounds like an album crushed within an inch of it's life onto one of those 128mb mp3 players back in the day, coming at you at 12kb/s or some other ghastly quality. It fizzes like a broken bottle of coke in a tin can. I kind of wish there was a version that sounded a bit less raw, but I guess it adds to the charm somewhat. The songwriting and vocals are superb. I mean I've no idea what she's singing about, it's Japanese, but she does it with passion and some crescendos that are surely the most magnificent of the year - e.g Gips. A Jackson Pollock painting of musical ideas crushed through an alt-rock filter.

Song Pick: Gips

8/10

Station, Advantage Lucy’s second album, is another irresistibly joyful record from the Japanese band. It’s a little more eclectic than Fanfare, but it’s equally well composed and just as infectious. I’ve no idea what is being sung, but I feel the need to go running through a field of sunflowers while looking at the sky. I feel happy.

Song Picks: How Do You Feel?, Memai, Kaze ni Azukete, Shumatsu

9/10

“Dopethrone is the third studio album by English band Electric Wizard. Vocalist and guitarist Jus Oborn has stated that drug issues and other personal problems led to the production of Dopethrone being a "difficult process". The album was recorded in three days. The music on the album has been described as both doom metal and stoner rock, with influences of British groups like Black Sabbath and Motörhead.” - Wikipedia

I had no idea what to expect going into this - but I certainly didn’t expect it to immediately become one of my favourite metal albums. Dopethrone sounds polished in terms of the performances, but there’s a raw edge to the rumbling guitars and bass, which are dropped so low they often sound like the roar of some primordial beast. The riffs are clearly Black Sabbath inspired, but these are gnarlier. Osborn’s vocals are distorted - often beyond intelligibility - and this, along with his gritty style, makes for a perfect spice on top of the mass of noise, adding to the tapestry of the sound, rather than doing anything front and centre. After 76 minutes of being pulverised by this, I immediately wanted to put it on again, which is high praise.

9/10

9. Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea

PJ Harvey

“Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea is the fifth studio album by the English singer-songwriter PJ Harvey. It contains themes of love that are tied into Harvey's affection for New York City. The album became the second major commercial success of her recording career, following her successful breakthrough To Bring You My Love (1995). Upon its release, the album received acclaim from most music critics and earned Harvey several accolades, including the 2001 Mercury Prize.” - Wikipedia

Stories from… is PJ Harvey’s The Bends in that it’s her most poppy and accessible album. Gone are the serrated edges of her previous records - replaced with sumptuous reverb and floating melodies. It’s also her The Bends because it’s packed front to back with great songs, a real display of Harvey’s songwriting talent.

Song Picks: Big Exit, A Place Called Home, This Mess We're In, You Said Something, This Is Love, We Float

9/10

“Voodoo is the second studio album by the American singer, songwriter, and multi-instrumentalist D'Angelo, Produced primarily by the singer, Voodoo features a loose, groove-based funk sound and serves as a departure from the more conventional song structure of his debut album, Brown Sugar (1995). Its lyrics explore themes of spirituality, love, sexuality, maturation, and fatherhood. Voodoo has since been regarded by music writers as a creative milestone of the neo soul genre during its apex.” - Wikipedia

Silky falsettos and soft beats, whole grain soul food. Infinitely relistenable - this is music.

Song Picks: Playa Playa, The Line, Send it On, Feel Like Makin' Love

9.5/10

7. Relationship of Command

At the Drive-In

“Relationship of Command is the third studio album by American post-hardcore band At the Drive-In. The album combines an aggressive edge with a melodic drive, harmonious, emotive vocals, and surreal lyrics. Initially received positively by critics, the album is now seen not only as one of the most influential post-hardcore albums of the 2000s, but also as one of the most accomplished recent works in the wider rock spectrum. It was the band's final album to feature founding guitarist Jim Ward.” - Wikipedia

I’m not quite as obsessed with this album as I once was, but I still think it’s an absolutely superb mix of anger, insatiable energy, melodies, and chaos. Their famous Later With Jools Holland performance sums up what they must be like to see live (brilliantly mad), but what’s more impressive is how that live, messy energy comes across on the recorded album. I think I can count on one hand the albums that have managed that, and I think this is probably the best of them.

Song Picks: One Armed Scissor, Sleepwalk Capsule, Invalid Litter Dept

9.5/10

6. And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out

Yo La Tengo

“And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside-Out is the ninth studio album by American indie rock band Yo La Tengo. The album received acclaim from critics and is generally considered one of their best.” - Wikipedia

On And Then Nothing… Yo La Tengo drop down a gear in terms of urgency, but turn up the depth and atmosphere. This is a gorgeous, contemplative record of melodic mumbles over lush, spacious backing. It makes a perfect 'walking through the city at night' double-header with the Clientelle album on this list. Its instruments twinkle like far away windows in a tower block - hundreds of lives illuminated but mysterious. The whole album is a masterpiece of gentleness and empathy, and on that note, Tears are In Your Eyes is surely one of the prettiest songs ever written.

Song Picks: Last Days of Disco, Tears are In Your Eyes, The Crying of Lot G, You Can Have it All

9.5/10

“Mama's Gun is the second studio album by American singer Erykah Badu. A neo soul album, Mama's Gun incorporates elements of funk, soul, and jazz styles. It has confessional lyrics by Badu, which cover themes of insecurity, personal relationships, and social issues. The album has been viewed by critics as a female companion to neo soul artist D'Angelo's second album Voodoo (2000), which features a similar musical style and direction. Critics have also noted that while Badu's first album Baduizm contained its share of cryptic lyricism, Mama's Gun is much more direct in its approach, and places the artist in a subjective position more than its predecessor.” - Wikipedia

Voodoo and Mama’s Gun are so closely linked - having been recorded in the same studio at thesame time - and they’re both masterpieces, but Mama’s Gun just takes the crown for me. The luxurious grooves and melodies are aided by Badu’s silky smooth vocals, and a touch more variety than D’Angelo’s effort. It also has a punkier, more in your face sensibility that I like.

Song Picks: Penitentiary Philosophy, Didn't Chat Know, Green Eyes

9.5/10

“Since I Left You is the debut studio album by Australian electronic music group the Avalanches. The album was recorded and produced at two separate, near-identical studios by Chater and Seltmann, exchanging audio mixes of records they sampled. After the album's positive reception in Australia, the duo considered an international release. Since I Left You was acclaimed by critics. It became one of the best-reviewed albums of the 2000s, and was listed at number ten in the book 100 Best Australian Albums.” - Wikipedia

Their self titled follow up to this has always been one of my favourites, so it's no surprise I love this one too. Sampling at its most pure and brilliant, Since I Left You combines a plethora of samples to create something completely joyful, cohesive, and full of soul. It's like a front row ticket to one of the best DJ sets of all time, where everyone, including you, is on happy drugs. Its deliberate tilt to more of a 60/70s sound than most sampled music helped it stick out, but it's the musical execution and brilliance of the Australian duo that makes it what it. Since I Left You is a miracle.

Song Picks: Since I left you, Stay another season, A Different Feeling, Tonight May Have to Last Me All My Life, Frontier Psychiatrist, Summer Crane

9.5/10

“The Moon & Antarctica is the third studio album by American rock band Modest Mouse. The Moon & Antarctica received acclaim from critics, who praised its subject matter and change in sound from earlier albums and frontman Isaac Brock's introspective lyrics. It was also hailed for being an expansion of the band's sound, much due to their new major label budget as well as the production of Brian Deck.” - Wikipedia

The Moon and Antarctica is such a perfect amorphous gem of an album, to spend too much time describing it is almost impossible for me. As weird as its cover, it strips back some of the trance inducing riffs of The Lonesome Crowded West, making it a little more immediate. Brock has one of those voices that sticks out in a good way, and his melodies and lyrics are on absolute peak form here, worming their way into my subconscious and making my soul smile. The guitar work is absolutely superb too - with winding riffs and spacey progressions befitting the album’s title and theme. It’s more than the sum of its parts, and its parts are superb.

I think The Moon and Antarctica will forever remain mysterious to me, much like the bodies it's named after, and it’s that sense of mystery that makes me feel like I’m discovering an absolute favourite for the first time every time I put it on. I can’t think of any other album that so reliably gives me that feeling.

Song Picks: I think the opening three songs is one of my favourite trios to open an album ever.

10/10

“Suburban Light is the debut studio album by English indie pop band the Clientele. Suburban Light contains several tracks originally released on singles and compilations from 1997 through 2000, causing some websites such as Pitchfork to label it a compilation album.” - Wikipedia

As Wikipedia says, technically, it’s a compilation album, but I don’t care. Like that lovely cover (the less common of its two covers), Suburban Light is a blurry, colourful, rain soaked drive through the night on a bus. McKeen’s vocals are hushed and melodic, the guitar twinkles are undefined, the drums are brushed - everything is done with a kind of relaxed uncertainty. It’s one of the most comforting albums you’ll ever hear and I’ve yet to find, in probably hundreds of listens, a time when I haven’t been completely charmed by it. If I was asked to recommend one album that most people hadn’t heard of, it would be this. But, I’d add to go listen to it sat in the back of a city bus at night. I’m pretty sure everyone would end that journey in love with it. It also contains, what I think, is one of the most beautiful songs ever written: (I Want You) More Than Ever.

Song Picks: I Had to Say This, (I Want You) More Than Ever, Bicycles

10/10

“Kid A is the fourth studio album by the English rock band Radiohead. Departing from their earlier sound, Radiohead incorporated influences from electronic music, krautrock, jazz and 20th-century classical music, with a wider range of instruments and effects. The singer, Thom Yorke, wrote impersonal and abstract lyrics, cutting up phrases and assembling them at random.

In a departure from industry practice, Radiohead released no singles and conducted few interviews and photoshoots. Instead, they released short animations and became one of the first major acts to use the internet for promotion. Bootlegs of early performances were shared on filesharing services, and Kid A was leaked before release. In 2000, Radiohead toured Europe in a custom-built tent without corporate logos.

Kid was certified platinum in the UK, the US, Australia, Canada, France and Japan. Its new sound divided listeners, and some dismissed it as pretentious or derivative. However, at the end of the decade, Rolling Stone, Pitchfork and the Times ranked it the greatest album of the 2000s, and in 2020 Rolling Stone ranked it number 20 on its updated list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.” - Wikipedia

Kid A is an album I’ve loved since I first got into it. It took a few listens, but the first time I listened to it at night, I got it and it blew me away. Somewhere on a night-bus in Central America I was whisked away to a world of melancholy electronic music that lit the lonely, beaten road ahead in a gorgeous hue. The bumps, the stars, the dark behind the trees, everything somehow became even more beautiful under Kid A’s gaze. Thom Yorke’s vocals don’t get enough praise, but he sounds like a beautiful, tormented angel as always, and they tie together this album’s many influences brilliantly, as does the crystal clean electronic sound of the record. Kid A is an album that has soundtracked so many phases of my life - I’ve turned to it in sadness in the past, and in contentment more recently - and it never fails to light a swaying candle somewhere inside me. It’s also another album that has great tracks but is so much more than the sum of its parts - perfectly paced, cohesive and bewitching from start to finish.

The album feels to me like a musical expression of a city’s quieter streets at night-time. A sprinkling of humans struggling with the daily task of being human - while looking left and right and finding solace in those they don’t know doing the same.

Song Picks: Everything In Its Right Place, The National Anthem, How to Disappear Completely, Optimistic, Idioteque, Motion Picture Soundtrack

10/10

1997 - Clive's Top Albums of Every Year Challenge

July 08, 2024 by Clive in Clive's Album Challenge, Music

Over what will likely be the next few years I’m going to be ranking and reviewing the top 5 albums - plus a fair few extras - according to users on rateyourmusic.com (think IMDB for music) from every year from 1960 to the present. If you want to know more, I wrote an introduction to the ‘challenge’ here. You can also read all the other entries I’ve written so far by heading to the lovely index page here.

1997, the year I turned 10, Titanic was released and became the highest grossing movie in history at the time, the first Harry Potter book was released and the sovereignty of Hong Kong was passed from the UK to the People’s Republic of China, and perhaps most famously here in the UK, Princess Diana died.

Here’s the top rated albums of the year by the music nerds over at rateyourmusic.com:

#1 Radiohead - OK Computer
#2 Bjork - Homogenic
#3 Godspeed You Black Emperor! - F#A#
#4 Elliot Smith - Either / Or
#5 Modest Mouse - The Lonesome Crowded West

And some from further down the list:

#6 Built to Spill - Perfect from Now On
#7 Fishmans - Uchū Nippon Setagaya
#8 Stereolab - Dots and Loops
#9 Janet Jackson - The Velvet Rope
#10 Ween - The Mollusk
#13 Yo La Tengo - I Can Hear the Heart Beating as One

And a couple more albums by women from NPR’s list.

Sleater-Kinney - Dig Me Out
Erykah Badu - Baduizm

Let’s go.

“The Mollusk is the sixth studio album by American rock band Ween. It is a multi-genre concept album with a dark nautical theme, with most songs incorporating elements from psychedelia and/or sea shanties, while also featuring a heavy progressive rock influence.” - Wikipedia

I really liked this on first listen, it reminded me of a what a whole album of ‘I am the Walrus’ era Ringo Starr might have sounded like. But on subsequent listens it just felt like too much, and I very quickly burnt out on it. A shame.

6/10

“Uchū Nippon Setagaya (Japanese: 宇宙日本世田谷) is the seventh and final studio album by Japanese dream pop band Fishmans. The album's title roughly translates to Space, Japan, Setagaya. After signing a deal with Polydor Records for a three-album deal, Fishmans put out Kuchu Camp and Long Season (both 1996). The band returned to their studio, Waikiki Beach, to record a third album, but the band was plagued with internal struggle. Frontman Shinji Sato would often come to rehearsals with nearly-complete home demo recordings, which alienated the other members of the band. This would be the band's last studio album before initially disbanding, but was followed up by two live albums, 8月の現状 (1998), and 98.12.28 男達の別れ (1999). Sato died from lifelong heart conditions three months after the recording of the latter.” - Wikipedia

This is all very lovely and I particularly like the continuously melodic bass-work which has an almost dub feel to it. However, it just isn’t as compelling as their previous effort Long Seasons in my view. It feels safer and cosier, but in a way that makes it more background music for me than something I’m going to get really lost in.

Song Picks: Pokka Pokka, Weather Report

7/10

“Either/Or is the third studio album by American singer-songwriter Elliott Smith. Book-ended by its two singles, "Speed Trials" and "Ballad of Big Nothing", Either/Or did not chart in the US, but was acclaimed by critics.” - Wikipedia

Smith’s songwriting prowess is evident here, but I’m just not getting into it as much as I have his self-titled album, maybe it sounds a bit too glossy? Dunno. It’s in the ‘thoroughly pleasant’ rather than ‘wow’ camp for me, but I know I’m an outlier.

Song Picks: Rose Parade, Say Yes

7/10

“The Velvet Rope is the sixth studio album by American singer Janet Jackson. Prior to its release, she renegotiated her contract with Virgin for US$80 million, marking this as the largest recording contract in history at that time. Upon experiencing an emotional breakdown, Jackson began facing a long-term case of depression. She developed her new record as a concept album, using introspection as its theme.” - Wikipedia

I’ve never been massively into straight 90s (or early 2000s) pop, there’s just something a bit sanitised about it that I can’t quite put my finger on. The Velvet Rope has much more interesting production than other pop albums of the time, but it still has that overly clean 90s sound which just tends to skim off me like a well thrown pebble on the water. I very much appreciate Jackson’s lyrical content here, which is anything but sanitised, and her melodies are as wonderful as ever. There’s some absolute 90s pop bangers here with Got ‘Til It’s Gone, Together Again, I Get Lonely and Every Time all being some of the decade’s best pop-tracks, and ones that still see plenty of airplay today. For me it’s a smidge too long, but undoubtedly one of the strongest straight-pop albums of the decade. On a side note, she sounds particularly like her brother on this album, especially on the softer tracks.

Song Picks: You, Got ‘Til It’s Gone, Together Again, I Get Lonely, Every Time

8/10

“Dig Me Out is the third studio album by the American rock band Sleater-Kinney. Dig Me Out marked the debut of Janet Weiss, who would become the band's longest-serving drummer. The music on the record was influenced by traditional rock and roll bands, while the lyrics deal with issues of heartbreak and survival. The album was acclaimed by music critics, who praised the album's energy and feminist lyrics. Retrospectively, Dig Me Out is considered the band's breakthrough record and is frequently included on several publications' best album lists. In 2020, Rolling Stone ranked it No. 189 on its list of The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.” - Wikipedia

Corin Tucker’s vocals are just the right side of piercing, with a tone and passion that cuts right through the mix, helped by how uncluttered things generally are from this three-piece, who forgo any studio trickery for a very raw sound. Dig Me Out is a superb, no-nonsense punk record, representing an important feminist message that has been all too rare in music to this point.

Song Picks: One More Hour, The Drama You’ve Been Craving

8.5/10

**8. F# A#** ∞

Godspeed You! Black Emperor

“F♯ A♯ ∞ (pronounced "F-sharp, A-sharp, Infinity") is the debut studio album by Canadian post-rock band Godspeed You! Black Emperor. The CD version and the LP version have substantial differences between them. Recorded at the Hotel2Tango in the Mile End of Montreal, the album, as became common for the band, is devoid of traditional lyrics and is mostly instrumental, featuring lengthy songs segmented into movements. Pitchfork ranked the album number 45 on their list of the top 100 albums of the 1990s.” - Wikipedia

F♯ A♯ ∞ feels like the stomp to a final post-apocalyptic battle, it rolls with the rhythm of a march, and swells with the emotion of knowing that this is the end. A gloriously evocative record.

8.5/10

“Perfect from Now On is the third full-length album released by Built to Spill, and the band's first major label (Warner Bros.) release. Stylistically, the album was marked by its experimentation with longer song structures and philosophical lyrics.” - Wikipedia

I’m unsurprised to hear Built to Spill were a key influence on Ben Gibbard of Death Cab for Cutie, as Doug Martsch’s vocal style and ear for melody is very similar. Musically they’re a bit more jam orientated than Death Cab for Cutie, with long, often raucous instrumental sections filling out the gaps in vocals. Clearly influential on a whole raft of late 90s and early 2000s indie, Perfect from Now On is a wonderful blend of affecting vocals, simple lyrics, and slightly off-kilter instrumental parts unafraid to march off a cliff and see what happens. It feels like emo and an atmospheric, edgy jam band had a baby. Martsch’s guitar work deserves a mention too, picking you up like an errant sandworm and smashing you into the horizon, Velvet Waltz being a particularly great example of this.

Song Picks: Really Described Eternity, I Would Hurt a Fly, Mad-up Dreams, Velvet Waltz, Kicked it in the Sun

8.5

“Baduizm is the debut studio album by American singer-songwriter Erykah Badu. After leaving university in order to concentrate on music full-time, Badu then began touring with her cousin, Robert "Free" Bradford, and recorded a 19-song demo, Country Cousins, which attracted the attention of Kedar Massenburg. He set Badu up to record a duet with D'Angelo, "Your Precious Love," and eventually signed her to a record deal with Universal. Baduizm was a commercial success, debuting at number two on the US Billboard 200 chart and number one on the Billboard Top R&B/Hip-Hop Albums.” - Wikipedia

Like one of those chill-hop study playlists but with a hundred times more soul. Badu's buttery smooth vocals effortlessly express melodies over a wholesome bedding of bass and snare claps. It all unravels at a pace so leisurely it feels like it might fall over any second. Sublime.

Song Picks: On & On, Appletree, Certainly

8.5/10

“Homogenic is the third studio album by Icelandic recording artist Björk. The album marked a stylistic change, focusing on similar-sounding music combining electronic beats and string instruments with songs in tribute to her native country Iceland. Homogenic was originally to be produced in her home in London, but was halted due to media attention from Björk surviving a murder attempt by a stalker. Homogenic has continued receiving critical acclaim, being listed among the best albums of all time by numerous critics.” - Wikipedia

Bjork can always be relied upon to make albums that stand out creatively, and Homogenic is no exception. Pounding, crystal soundscapes back Bjork’s soaring vocals like a beam of light taking them to the heavens. It’s an album not of songs as such, but of moments, where repeated phrases bore their way into your brain, often finally driven home by Bjork’s roar. Homogenic’s use of electronic programming seems very ahead of its time, and I can here lots of later Radiohead here for example. Engaging from start to finish, and so very interesting.

Song Picks: Unravel, 5 years, Jóga, Alarm Call

9/10

“Dots and Loops is the fifth studio album by English-French rock band Stereolab. It was their first album to be recorded straight to Digital Audio Tape and produced with Pro Tools. The album explores jazz and electronic sounds, and is influenced by bossa nova and 1960s pop music. Its lyrics address matters such as consumerism, the "spectacle", materialism, and human interaction. Several music critics have praised Dots and Loops for its blend of accessible music with experimental and avant-garde sounds.” - Wikipedia

Dots and Loops warms up the room like an exotic fire in the corner. It turns rainy days to sunshine. Is there anything more essential if you live in the UK? Probably not. It’s well over an hour long, but never outstays its welcome, in fact I’ve more often than not found myself starting it again as soon as it’s finished.

Song Picks: Miss Modular, Brakhage

9/10

3. The Lonesome Crowded West

Modest Mouse

“The Lonesome Crowded West is the second studio album by American rock band Modest Mouse. The two towers pictured on the album's cover are The Westin Seattle The Lonesome Crowded West received positive reviews from critics, and appeared on several lists of the best albums of the 1990s.” - Wikipedia

Here’s what I said back when I first reviewed this album back in 2013:

“Another Modest Mouse album at the top. This one’s essentially inspired by the ‘Mallfucking’ of America (as singer Isaac Brock puts it) and also by the experiences of a band being on the road. It’s wacky, it’s memorable and it’s long (around 78 minutes). The main reason for the album’s length is that the band often breaks into impromtu jams and while most producers would have cut these short to make the songs more radio ready I’m glad this wasn’t done here. It really has the raw feel of a band at the top of their game having fun without barriers. As with The Moon & Antarctica last month I love the sheer variation in the songs, hell even within one song, ‘Teeth Like God’s Shoeshine’ being a prime example, you can have screaming one second, tender bits the next, and a complete change of rhythm and time signature the next. Like The Moon and Antarctica it’s a journey, this time slightly more raw, but with no less passion. I also have to mention Jeremiah Green’s excellent drumming, top drawer stuff and the bass (particularly on the groovy songs inspired by being on the road such as Out of Gas) is awesome.. This is a great, great album and Modest Mouse are swiftly making their way into my very favourite bands.”

You know what 2013 Clive, I still agree. I feel like the review needs more daft analogies though to really fit into the context of this challenge. ‘The Lonesome Crowded West is like a pacing, friendly tiger. It walks backwards and forwards with a sense of unspent energy, a sense of frustration needing release, but satisfying itself instead by slowly deflating via the low rumbling purr of its endless great basslines.’

There we go. That’s better.

Song Picks: Teeth Like God’s Shoeshine, Convenient Parkin’, Doin’ the Cockroach, Trailer Trash, Out of Gas, Trucker’s Atlas

9.5/10

2. I Can Hear the Heart Beating as One

Yo La Tengo

“I Can Hear the Heart Beating as One is the eighth studio album by the American indie rock band Yo La Tengo. The album expands the guitar-based pop of its predecessor Electr-O-Pura to encompass a variety of other music genres, including bossa nova, krautrock, and electronic music. The album received widespread acclaim from music critics, who praised the band's ability to successfully expand the boundaries of nearly any pop style. The album is widely regarded as the band's best work and is frequently included on several publications' best album lists. In 2020, Rolling Stone included it on its list of The 500 Greatest Albums of All Time as no. 423.” - Wikipedia

I Can Hear the Heart Beating as One is magic. I’d listened to the album a few times and thought it was pleasant, but it was on a morning where I was playing with my son that it really hit home. There’s an understated beauty, variety, and melancholy to every track, in a way that is somehow full of hope. It’s rare that an album perfectly encapsulates your mood at a particular time, but I had one of those magical moments with this as I thought of the past, some of my struggles, and how it’s all ended up in a place where I finally feel content. And how I’d never change any of it, given where it’s led me.

The often mumbled vocals, those melodic basslines, the world music influences, the trance-like repetition, there’s something truly beautiful about the melancholy contentment it portrays.

Song Picks: Return Hot Chicken, Sugarcube, Little Honda

9.5/10

“OK Computer is the third studio album by the English rock band Radiohead. They distanced themselves from the guitar-centred, lyrically introspective style of their previous album, The Bends. OK Computer's abstract lyrics, densely layered sound and eclectic influences laid the groundwork for Radiohead's later, more experimental work. The album's lyrics depict a dystopian, futuristic world fraught with rampant consumerism, capitalism, social and modern alienation, emotional isolation and political malaise, with overall themes like transport, technology, insanity, death, modern British life, globalisation and anti-capitalism; in this capacity, OK Computer is said to have prescient insight into the mood of 21st-century life. The band used unconventional production techniques, including natural reverberation, and no audio separation. Most of the album was recorded live.” - Wikipedia

I’m not sure there’s much left to say about OK Computer, rateyourmusic.com’s current #1 album of all time, but I’ll try anyway. I’ve been looking forward to getting to 1997 to cover this ever since starting the challenge. The instrumental production is deliberately messy owing to the live sound and lack of instrument separation, and I feel this helps to bring Thom Yorke’s vocals and lyrics to the front, which are superb throughout. The way he soars above the storm of Airbag as he sings ‘an interstellar burst, I’m back to save the universe’ is one of the most life-affirming moments in music for me, not just this album; the way Paranoid Android batters around before settling into the gently strummed part as Yorke croons for it to rain on him, being another. OK Computer is irresistible musically, full of melody, chaos and feeling, but it does this while being a perfect statement on modern life. It’s both very accessible and very ambitious. I’m not clever enough to put my finger on exactly why, but more than any other album, it represents that feeling of growing up in the modern world.

Song Picks: Airbag, Paranoid Android, Subterranean Homesick Alien

1996 - Clive's Top Albums of Every Year Challenge

April 25, 2024 by Clive in Clive's Album Challenge, Music, Clive

Welcome to 1996 y’all, the year Britain was alarmed by an outbreak of mad cow disease, the world’s first sheep was cloned and named Dolly, Tupac Shakur was shot, and Clinton appointed the first female US secretary of state, Madeleine Albright.

Here’s rateyourmusic.com users’ top 5 albums of the year:

#1 Fishmans - Long Season
#2 DJ Shadow - Endtroducing
#3 Swans - Soundtracks for the Blind
#4 Outkast - ALiens
#5 Belle and Sebastian - If You’re Feeling Sinister

Obviously 5 isn’t enough now is it? So I’ve grabbed this lot from further down the list:

#6 Cryptopsy - None So Vile
#7 Burzum - Filosofem
#8 Unwound - Repetition
#9 Tool - Aenima
#10 Weezer - Pinkerton
#11 Aphex Twin - Richard D. James Album
#16 Ruyichi Sakamoto - 1996
#26 Modest Mouse - This Is a Long Drive for Someone With Nothing to Think About
#17 Tori Amos - Boys for Pele

And finally, One in a Million by Aaliyah, the only album from the year on NPR’s best albums of all time by women list that I haven’t already got in the mix.

Right, let’s go.

As smooth as those secret agent sunglasses she’s wearing on the cover, One in a Million is a remarkably mature effort considering Aaliyah was only 15 at the time. At times this maturity is somewhat alarming, considering the topics she is singing about. Linked to that, I’ll not mention the producer of this album, who is thankfully now in prison, but I will mention Timbaland who’s simple and effective beats work a treat with Aaliyah’s great vocals. Looked at purely from a musical perspective, One in a Million is a real treat.

Song Picks: Choosey Lover

8/10

“Filosofem (Norwegian for "Philosopheme") is the fourth studio album by Norwegian black metal solo project Burzum. It was recorded in March 1993 and was the last recording before Varg Vikernes was sentenced to prison in 1994; the album was not released until January 1996, however. It was released through Misanthropy Records and Vikernes's own record label, Cymophane Productions. The album is noted for its experimental sound when compared to most other second wave black metal. Vikernes considers Filosofem an "anti-trend album." - Wikipedia

Imprisoned for stabbing another leading guitarist in the Norwegian black metal scene and burning down three churches, and notorious for his controversial views and a period of neo-Nazism, Varg Vikernes is hardly someone you want to model yourself on. All that aside though, and knowing close to nothing about the Norwegian black metal movement (other than it seems a bit mad), this is an album of pulverising riffs and screams, all seemingly routed through a distortion pedal with the drive knob on max. It’s a fuzzy sandstorm, where Vikernes’ screams are indecipherable above the din, which is probably for the best. I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed this, it’s fuzziness seemingly the equivalent of drinking a pint through a straw, it goes to your head that much quicker.

It will also now forever remind me of a time at Rock Im Park festival when a Norwegian bloke was brought back to our campsite after a Rage Against the Machine gig. He spent the next morning charging around the campsite naked screaming ‘let’s burn churches!!’ while throwing peoples’ tents around before being arrested.

Song Picks: Jesus’ Tod, Erblicket die Tochter des Firmaments

8/10

13. This Is a Long Drive for Someone With Nothing to Think About

Modest Mouse

“This Is a Long Drive for Someone with Nothing to Think About is the debut studio album by American rock band Modest Mouse. Many of the album's tracks focus on traveling by automobile and the loneliness associated with rural life.” - Wikipedia

Modest Mouse’s debut is long, simple and repetitive musically. But it’s also full of Isaac Brock’s unique vocals, and lyrics of loneliness and long journeys. It rumbles along like a rusty car along a long, empty American highway. Reflections of the past and visions of the future like alternating magnets to the mind.

Song Picks: Dramamine, Tundra/Desert

8/10

“Ænima is the second studio album by the American rock band Tool. It is the first album by Tool to feature bassist Justin Chancellor, who replaced original bassist Paul D'Amour the year prior. In 2003, Ænima was ranked the sixth most influential album of all time by Kerrang!, Rolling Stone listed the album at No. 18 on its list of The 100 Greatest Metal Albums of All Time.” - Wikipedia

Weird time signatures, pulverising riffs and drum beats that pound like a blue whale’s heart. This is a powerful album from a band on the way up. The album is clearly hugely influential, so much so that listening now it all sounds a bit generic. Effective, head bangingly enjoyable, and with a satisfying ‘mathiness’ to it, Ænima is a little too repetitive to blow my socks off completely, but they have been slightly dislodged.

Song Picks: Stinkfist, Forty Six & 2

8/10

“None So Vile is the second studio album by Canadian death metal band Cryptopsy, None So Vile is the first album to feature bassist Eric Langlois, and the last to feature vocalist Lord Worm, until his return on 2005's Once Was Not. The art featured on the cover of the album is a painting by Italian Baroque painter Elisabetta Sirani titled Herodias with the Head of John the Baptist, reversed. None So Vile is critically acclaimed as one of the most influential death metal albums of the 1990s, influencing many later acts and musicians in both technical death and brutal death metal subgenres.” - Wikipedia

I think I’ve called albums a barrage of noise before, but forget I ever said that, this album makes those feel like your ear being tickled. The bass drum barely stops bashing out 16th notes, there’s roaring, guitars churning hyperactive riffs and general ordered chaos. A slice of relentless brutality.

Song Picks: Crown of Horns, Slit Your Guts, Orgiastic Disembolwment

8.5/10

“1996 is a 1996 album by Japanese composer and pianist Ryuichi Sakamoto. It contains a selection of Sakamoto's most popular compositions plus two new compositions, all arranged for a standard piano trio. The arrangement of "Bibo no Aozora" that appears on this album has appeared in several film and television projects; one notable example is the film Babel, whose soundtrack features both the 1996 version and the /04 version of the song.” - Wikipedia

Where this could have been in danger of sounding like a greatest hits collection, the re-arrangement of songs for a standard piano trio means there is a real cohesiveness in the sound throughout the album, which helps to reign in some of the thematic inconsistencies. This is a wonderful collection of evocative and yet understated soundtrack pieces.

Song Picks: Bibo No Aozora, Merry Christmas Mr Lawrence

8.5/10

“ATLiens is the second studio album by the American hip hop duo Outkast. The record features outer space-inspired production sounds, with Outkast and producers Organized Noize incorporating elements of dub and gospel into the compositions. Several songs feature the duo's first attempts at producing music by themselves. Lyrically, the group discusses a wide range of topics including urban life as hustlers, existential introspection, and extraterrestrial life. The album's title is a portmanteau of "ATL" (an abbreviation of Atlanta, Georgia, the duo’s hometown) and "aliens", which has been interpreted by critics as a commentary about the feeling of being isolated from American culture. Since its release, ATLiens has been listed by several magazines and critics as one of the greatest hip-hop albums of all time.” - Wikipedia

I bloody love 90s hip-hop, and this album encapsulates why. Smooth beats, slick rhymes, not taking itself to seriously - and space noises. Okay the last one is specific to this album. It’s a bit long, and front loaded - though more in a first half is magical, second half just great kind of a way. I didn’t think I’d ever rate an album with the lines ‘put your hands in the air and wave them like you just don’t care’ this highly, but it’s delivered with a knowing wink and the larger-than-life personality that’s spread thick throughout this odyssey.

Song Picks: "Two Dope Boyz (In a Cadillac)", “ATLiens“

8.5/10

“Repetition is the fifth studio album by the American post-hardcore band Unwound, the album has been hailed as a masterpiece among those in the punk rock scene.” - Wikipedia

Taking a more studio-orientated approach than is perhaps common in punk, Repetition goes far beyond the usual ‘three chords and the truth’, live oriented sound of the genre, with sleek production and intricately thought out arrangements. The title is apt, as songs often feature repetitive, rumbling bass which create a foundation for the album’s more experimental guitar screeches, synth drones, gongs and bells. Repetition can be as emotional (Lady Elect) as it is energetic (Corpse Pose), and it’s easily one of the most interesting and varied punk albums I’ve heard.

Song Picks: Corpse Pose, Lady Elect, For Your Entertainment

8.5/10

“Pinkerton is the second studio album by the American rock band Weezer. The guitarist and vocalist Rivers Cuomo wrote most of Pinkerton while studying at Harvard University, after abandoning plans for a rock opera, Songs from the Black Hole. It was the last Weezer album to feature bassist Matt Sharp, who left the group in 1998.

To better capture their live sound, Weezer self-produced Pinkerton, creating a darker, more abrasive album than their self-titled 1994 debut. Cuomo's lyrics express loneliness and disillusionment with the rock lifestyle; the album is named after the character BF Pinkerton from Giacomo Puccini's 1904 opera Madama Butterfly, whom Cuomo described as an ‘asshole American sailor similar to a touring rock star’”. - Wikipedia

Voted the third worst album of the year by Rolling Stone readers at the time, it has since become known as a masterpiece, and a huge influence on the emo scene. Pinkerton’s lyrics are simple, at times cringeworthy in content (sniffing an 18 year old fan’s knickers anyone?), but I feel like that’s the point. It’s written from the perspective of the asshole touring rockstar Cuomo is referring to, which is of course him. Matt Sharp’s bass rumbles throughout, determined to make his last album with the band count. The guitars saw, and the drums sound massive. It’s an album that sounds raw, but that hits hard, a perfect backdrop to Cuomo’s self-pitying, immature musings, which are sung to an endless selection of catchy melodies.

I have no desire to be friends with the Cuomo who wrote Pinkerton, he sounds insufferable. But I do appreciate how honest he is about it, and how his and the band’s energy practically explodes off the disc, or cloud streaming service - whatever the case may be.

Song Picks: Why Bother?, Butterfly, El Scorcho

8.9/10

“Richard D. James Album is the eponymous fourth studio album by Irish-British electronic musician Richard D. James, under his pseudonym Aphex Twin. Richard D. James Album was composed by James on his Macintosh computer, and took longer to complete than his previous efforts. The album features faster breakbeats and intricate drum programming which draw influence from jungle and drum and bass, combined with lush string arrangements, unstable time signatures, and slow ambient melodies reminiscent of James' earlier work, as well as modulated vocals by James.” - Wikipedia

32 minutes of electronic madness. The beats sound like a drum machine becoming sentient and expressing a complex bewilderment with the world. The instrumentation goes from ambient (though with notes not quite starting or finishing when you’d expect) to completely off the wall (Carn Marth). The cover would have you believe this is somehow sinister. It isn’t, it’s just completely unpredictable and glorious fun, and the final salvo of tracks are some of the most life-affirming I’ve heard for a while.

Song Picks: To Cure a Weakling Child, ‘4’, Goon Gumpas, Girl/Boy Song

9/10

“Boys for Pele is the third studio album by American singer and songwriter Tori Amos. P Despite the album being Amos's least radio friendly material to date, Boys for Pele debuted at number two on both the US Billboard 200 and the UK Albums Chart, making it her biggest simultaneous transatlantic debut, her first Billboard top 10 debut, and the highest-charting US debut of her career to date.

Boys for Pele was recorded in rural Ireland and Louisiana and features 18 songs that incorporate harpsichord, clavichord, harmonium, gospel choirs, brass bands and full orchestras. Amos wrote all of the tracks, and for the first time, she served as sole producer for her own album. For Amos, the album was a step into a different direction, in terms of singing, songwriting, and recording, and is experimental in comparison to her previous work.” - Wikipedia

70 minutes of varied instrumentation, wonderful songwriting, and vocals that are constantly engaging, with melodies seemingly falling to Tori like raindrops in a British drizzle. Boys for Pele captivates for its full, significant running length.

Song Picks: Beauty Queen/Horses, Father Lucifer

9/10

4. If You’re Feeling Sinister

Belle and Sebastian

“If You're Feeling Sinister is the second album by the Scottish indie pop band Belle and Sebastian. It is often ranked among the best albums of the 1990s, including being ranked #14 in Pitchfork's list of Top 100 Albums of the 1990s. Band leader Stuart Murdoch said If You're Feeling Sinister is probably his best collection of songs in 2005.” - Wikipedia

Murdoch’s vocals are understated, sung shyly, and atop gorgeous arrangements that bounce along like a more relaxed Blonde on Blonde. All that considered. it’s pretty remarkable that his vocals demand your attention, and that is a testament to his great lyricism, story telling, and subtle expression. I hadn’t realised how far ahead they were (in terms of timeline) of obvious bands they’ve influenced like the Shins, Death Cab for Cutie, and pretty much any indie-pop band that followed them. They set a template here, but they also made an album that more than stands the test of time almost 30 years on.

Song Picks: Get Me Away from Here I’m Dying, The Stars of Track and Field, Seeing Other People. Me and the Major, If You’re Feeling Sinister

9.5/10

“Endtroducing..... is the debut studio album by American music producer DJ Shadow. It is an instrumental hip hop work composed almost entirely of samples from vinyl records. DJ Shadow produced Endtroducing over two years, using an Akai MPC60 sampler and little other equipment. He edited and layered samples to create new tracks of varying moods and tempos.

Endtroducing was ranked highly on various lists of the best albums of 1996, and has been acclaimed by critics as one of the greatest albums of the 1990s. It is considered a landmark recording in instrumental hip hop, with DJ Shadow's sampling techniques and arrangements leaving a lasting influence. In 2020, Rolling Stone magazine ranked Endtroducing 329th on its list of the 500 greatest albums of all time.” - Wikipedia

There’s not much left to say about DJ Shadow’s Endtroducing that hasn’t already been said. A masterpiece of sampling, clearly ahead of its time, and put together with a level of research akin to a PhD thesis. It continues to influence music across the spectrum today, while maintaining an alluring individuality that hums under its atmospheric beats and instrumental lines.

Song Picks: Building Steam With a Grain of Salt, The Number Song, Mutual Slump, Midnight in a Perfect World

9.5/10

“Long Season is the sixth studio album by Japanese musical group Fishmans. It consists of a single 35-minute composition based on the band's earlier song "Season". The album was released to modest success in the Japanese alternative scene, but was scarcely known outside Japan until the 2010s, and has since garnered critical acclaim and online media attention. Fishmans performed the entire Long Season album as one piece during their final live shows in December 1998, a recording of which was included on the album 98.12.28 男達の別れ.” - Wikipedia

Long Season feels like a 3 part symphony to me (though it is split into 5 sections on certain issues). It starts as a meditative walk through the park with your favourite album playing; reliably comforting. The middle section feels like a frantic distraction - you check your phone and the state of the world shatters your peace; Motegi’s drums are quiet but chaotic like the background hum of everything happening out of sight and earshot. Finally, you catch yourself, put the phone away, and look at the path winding off into the distance. There’s a feeling of elation as your favourite song comes on, but now you let the birds in as well as the shuffling stream. It’s all too much, you start running for no reason other than you feel too elated to stand still. There’s no one else around, you laugh, you collapse on a patch of grass, you feel about as happy as you ever have, maybe as happy as you ever will. You thank your fellow humans for the music, for without it you’re not sure you’d feel very much at all.

9.5/10

“Soundtracks for the Blind is the tenth studio album by Swans. It was intended, as suggested by the title, to function as a "soundtrack for a non-existent film." Upon its release, it received critical acclaim, but was the last studio album released by the band until 2010's My Father Will Guide Me up a Rope to the Sky.” - Wikipedia

Regularly listed among the 90s’ best albums, Soundtracks for the Blind’s Brian Eno influence is obvious. This is more in the ambient category than previous crushing efforts of theirs. In its over two hour running length it builds a whole new world around you through its numerous samples, grainy conversations and the occasional cathartic release. It sounds huge, but without stacking instrument upon instrument to create a wall of sound. Rather it creates these grinding, industrial soundscapes that are surprisingly tuneful. If the film this thing soundtracked did exist, I’d be very keen to see it. I imagine it as a tale of isolation, a factory worker taking the floor day by day with thousands of others, trying to restrain his soul from bursting through his enforced mechanical exterior. The machines rattle around him, he turns their noise pollution into melodies, and imagines talking over the top, or the odd scream.

Soundtracks for the Blind is completely unique, and completely unforgettable. Its not the kind of album you’ll be recommending to everyone necessarily, but for those among us seeking inventive, atmospheric music that goes beyond an idea of songs to focus more on creating an atmosphere than a set of hits, then you’ll be hard pressed to find another album that does that better than this.